A Law Switched Off Before It Started
New South Wales had modelled its underquoting law on rules already operating in Victoria. Its version was due to take effect on Tuesday. On Monday morning the premier, Chris Minns, put it on hold for up to a year.
The New South Wales changes were passed in June and modelled on laws already operating in Victoria. They would have banned agents from advertising a property at a price below a written offer the seller had already rejected. The penalty attached to that ban was set at up to $110,000, or three times the agent’s commission, whichever sum was larger.
Underquoting is the practice of advertising a property below the price the seller would actually accept, drawing buyers into a contest they cannot win.
The law and its fines are now paused for up to a year. The suspension came the morning before the provisions were due to commence, after a last-minute intervention by the premier, Chris Minns.
A Hole Ten Percent Deep
The decisive figure is not in the statute but in the market. Sydney home values have fallen 10.1% from their 2026 peak, according to data from Cotality. A rule written for one price direction was about to be switched on in the other.
The complaint that triggered the pause came from real estate agents in Kogarah, the premier’s own south Sydney electorate. Minns told reporters the concern “has come across my desk from real estate agents in my electorate.” [1] He said he thought the effect was unforeseen, adding: “It is something we’re going to have to deal with because it’s not the seller or the agent’s fault if the price of real estate is dropping, and the legislation at least intuitively believed that the prices would always rise.” [1]
The concern was that the laws could stop sellers from advertising at a lower price now that the market has fallen.
Under the Victorian measures, which took effect last month, sellers must reveal their reserve price at least one week before a sale, and agents must publish sale prices after a transaction completes. The New South Wales instrument regulated the floor of the advertisement; the Victorian instrument regulates disclosure of the reserve and of the final result.
The Arithmetic Outran the Law
The pause is the latest in a series of reversals by the state government in recent weeks. Last month it dropped parts of its plastics legislation, provisions that would have required cafes to offer customers who dine in the option of mugs and glasses instead of takeaway cups. Cost of living and pressure on small businesses sit among the issues driving that pattern, with One Nation and the Coalition applying the pressure ahead of the March state election.
The polling points to electoral pressure behind the timing. One Nation was at 26% of the primary vote in New South Wales in October, according to a Sydney Morning Herald Resolve poll — behind Labor on 30% and ahead of the Coalition on 23%. Internal Labor polling has suggested One Nation could win more than 20 seats in the lower house. The party added four more candidates to its six-person upper house ticket on Sunday, but has so far named only one lower house candidate, its state leader Mike Newman.
The minister who owns the legislation, fair trading and corrections minister Anoulack Chanthivong, had praised it as recently as 1 November, calling the changes “important reforms to put the hammer down on underquoting and stop homebuyers being taken for a ride.” [1] On Monday afternoon a spokesperson for the Minns government provided a statement from Chanthivong, who said the laws had been passed “at a different time and in a different economic and housing market.” He added: “People are already doing it tough, and the last thing we want is for laws designed to protect homebuyers to inadvertently make it harder for them to buy a home.” The decision, he said, was “not to proceed with the implementation of these changes today.” Chanthivong faces a preselection battle in his seat of Macquarie Fields, and Minns would not say on Monday whether he would intervene on the minister’s behalf. It is not the first time the minister has been overruled by the premier; he was previously overruled on rental and prison reforms.
A statute passed in June now has no start date, a market 10.1% below its peak, and a March election standing between the promise and the fine.
