🌿freegardner

EconPol

The First Rung Is Getting Harder to Reach

17 Nov 2026 · via Feeds.bbci.co.uk

The First Rung Is Getting Harder to Reach
AI-generated image

The First Rung Is Getting Harder to Reach

Nearly one million people aged between 16 and 24 in Britain are not in education, employment or training - a group the statistics call Neet. The acronym is ugly because the condition behind it is ugly: it describes a stretch of time with no timetable attached to it. The acronym is ugly because the condition behind it is ugly. It describes a stretch of time with no timetable attached to it.

A major review aimed at cutting that number will say that under-25s should be guaranteed job placements or training to help them find permanent work. Ahead of the report, Milburn warned that Britain risks a “lost generation” unless young people are prioritised. [1] The design could prove decisive, and the design is not yet public. What is public is the labour market the guarantee would have to work in.

Across the whole economy there were 690,000 jobs available in the August to October period this year, the lowest number since early 2021. [1] Strip out the swings of the pandemic, when firms shut and reopened and hiring lurched with them, and the count sits at its weakest level for 12 years. A promise written in a year like this one is a promise written against the grain. The gap between the promise and the thermometer is the space in which the whole argument lives.

A Postcode Decides the Odds

National figures hide the postcode, which is one of the strongest influences on a young person’s options. The Institute for Public Policy Research (IPPR), a think tank, used artificial intelligence to pick out job adverts that looked suitable for young people — broadly, roles asking for relatively little experience or education. It then set those vacancies against the size of the local 18-to-24 population. South Oxfordshire came out on top, with 387 suitable vacancies per 1,000 young people in that age band, the most of any local authority. [1] Rotherham came out bottom, with 53 per 1,000. One country, one set of labour market rules, and a gap of more than seven times between the best and worst local authority.

The First Rung Is Getting Harder to Reach (Image 1)

Apprenticeships are the traditional answer to the first-rung problem, and the numbers there run in an awkward direction. In England, 172,230 people aged 24 and under started an apprenticeship in 2025. The peak was 291,300, reached in 2012. Total apprenticeship starts have risen in recent years — but that rise has been driven by people aged 25 and over, after schemes for older workers were fully rolled out in 2008. The route expanded, and it expanded upwards, towards people who already had a work history. The under-24 route shrank while the total grew.

A guarantee can promise a placement; it cannot promise that the placement exists within reach of the person who needs it. In a district with 387 suitable vacancies per 1,000 young people, an offer is mostly an administrative task. In one with 53, the same offer demands a move, a longer commute than the bus route allows, or a job in a sector nobody had chosen. Policy is written nationally. It is shaped by local conditions. That is where the arithmetic of a lost generation is actually settled.

What the Advert Refuses to Say

Where the vacancies are is one question; what they are is another. Teaching had the highest average number of entry-level vacancies in the year to October, and most of those roles were teaching assistants, learning support staff and cover supervisors. Hospitality and catering came second, the sector that has traditionally given young people their first experience of work, and accounting and finance came third. Those rankings come from Adzuna, a large online jobs site, whose entry-level basket includes full-time roles marked entry-level, posts asking for up to two years of experience, graduate roles, internships and apprenticeships. It is a broad net, and it is still catching a narrow set of jobs. The top of the list is dominated by work that supports other people’s work.

Pay is where the picture thins out. Only about 40% of Adzuna’s jobs data for the year to October stated a salary, and that share varies widely by sector — so the averages below describe the employers who chose to be visible. Among the sectors with the largest number of entry-level jobs, the highest average salary was in engineering, at £30,530. The lowest was social care, at £25,880. A young person choosing between a first job in engineering and a first job in care is not only choosing a daily task. They are choosing between two starting points that sit £4,650 apart on average, before a single decision about hours, training or progression.

Prime Minister Andy Burnham recently urged businesses to start publishing salaries, ahead of plans to make pay details compulsory in job adverts. The country does not have one youth labour market; it has many, and most of them are smaller than a bus timetable.

The First Rung Is Getting Harder to Reach (Image 2)

Sources

  1. BBC — Quote source (original article)

Mentioned organisations (context, not sources)

← back to the garden